In any case, you’re technically correct that it’s Arabic, but I’d say the fact that those who don’t speak Arabic still use that word - makes it Islamic in function.
Language gets co-opted all the time. Atheists say “goodbye”, they don’t say “God be with you”.
This is the same logic I’m applying when I say “Allah” is Islamic; if a word gets co-opted to be ubiquitous outside of the origin, then the origin no longer matters within that context.
I’m confused. Do you think “Islamic” is a bad word?
I didn’t group multiple cultures? I grouped one, Muslims.
You don’t need to have an inside perspective to see that the overwhelming majority saying “Allah”, whether they speak Arabic or not, is a religious affect, regardless of it’s origin.
In any case, you’re technically correct that it’s Arabic, but I’d say the fact that those who don’t speak Arabic still use that word - makes it Islamic in function.
Oh like how the word “bye” is “Christianic” in function?
I’m not convinced that “bye” is “Christianic” in function.
I’d say it’s English in function, regardless of it’s origin.
deleted by creator
Language gets co-opted all the time. Atheists say “goodbye”, they don’t say “God be with you”.
This is the same logic I’m applying when I say “Allah” is Islamic; if a word gets co-opted to be ubiquitous outside of the origin, then the origin no longer matters within that context.
The term “Islamic” is my problem here.
Grouping multiple cultures together just because they have similar aspects from an outside perspective that isn’t even fully accurate just felt gross.
I’m confused. Do you think “Islamic” is a bad word?
I didn’t group multiple cultures? I grouped one, Muslims.
You don’t need to have an inside perspective to see that the overwhelming majority saying “Allah”, whether they speak Arabic or not, is a religious affect, regardless of it’s origin.