• 2 Posts
  • 1.58K Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 18th, 2023

help-circle












  • Carpenters trained on power tools will suddenly perform worse with hand tools than carpenters who were never given power tools.

    Now you are just making shit up. None of these examples are about people being trained on AI. The comparison would be if a carpenter using power tolls for 10 minutes, suddenly becomes worse at using the traditional tools he is trained to use.

    Your claim is baseless, there is no evidence for it, and the lack of any evidence of it, makes it an unreasonable assumption based on your prejudice alone, and should not be believed.

    Let people have AI and perform better with it.

    Again a very loaded statement, nobody is preventing anybody from using AI based on this research. But maybe people are not really performing better, or at least not always, it may depend on the task.

    Your logic is fundamentally flawed and inconsistent, and you seem to lack any ability to see this as a potential problem, so much so that it reeks of you having an agenda.

    Your flawed logic and prejudice does not beat 3 research papers.



  • The calculator test might be good for comparison, and I’m pretty sure if given the same amount of time, and one group being allowed to use calculator for half the test, that group would solidly outperform a group not using calculators at all.

    I was in 5th grade in 1975, and we were the first class to get calculators in 5th grade. Which became the standard for many years after.
    I have never heard complaints about students being less capable of understanding basic math problems because they use calculators. Although the idea of using calculators in schools were heavily debated. It’s similar to people not getting worse at spelling from using a dictionary.