• 5 Posts
  • 924 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 23rd, 2024

help-circle











  • Here’s the list of logos row by row so you don’t have to awkwardly ask what they are

    Steam (not FOSS)*
    “LL” (likely OP’s own design, not a FOSS project)*
    Zigbee
    Obsidian (not FOSS)*
    Brave
    Protonpass

    Tailscale*
    Home Assistant
    Raspberry Pi (not open HW)*
    Ubiquiti (not open HW)*
    Android (not really FOSS)*
    Signal

    DigitalOcean (service)*
    Ubuntu
    Linux
    Claude (not FOSS)*
    Proxmox
    Nextcloud
    Jellyfin (rotated)

    Trilium
    Nginx
    Tabby
    Bash
    Debian (rotated)
    Docker

    NodeJS
    Python
    HomeBox
    XPipe
    PiHole
    Prometheus
    Grafana

    * not in gallery of printable sticker images






  • FOSS source is here.

    The second “S” in “FOSS” is “software”. You did not publish software, just its output: bitmap assets needed to print the stickers. Thanks for CC-licensing your creative work but source would mean showing what’s under the hood. We don’t know how you sourced the images used in each triangular tile: generated to best correspond with AI? Matching pieces from Wikimedia Commons photos?

    Edit: Look closely at Arch for example. It’s clearly just the logo placed in a hexagon, approximated by a mosaic of 24 triangles with AI images of differing quality. Is that snow or whipped cream? How can PCB traces be as blurry as watercolor and go nowhere? At least they’re topical: for Arch the prompt was probably “mountain OR architecture OR arch OR technology”.

    Presumably, the process for each tile is this:

    1. you make some direct artistic choices to create the base image (place the logo in a hexagon, choose a background color, add a border)
    2. you make some indirect artistic choices: pick keywords/themes for the AI to use
    3. you use a script to divide the hexagon into 24 triangles (presumably with “overscan”)
    4. you use generative AI to stylize the triangles’ bitmaps according to thw keywords, perhaps regenerating bad output
    5. you use a script to reassemble the image

    To consider this open source, I’d expect you to at least post the scripts you used in steps 3 and 5. To consider this good open source, it should contain a guide detailing this process, best with examples. I’d expect the AI part will be “bring your own model” but you could tell which one you used and its settings.

    The idea is creative and “human” enough for me not to condemn it. “FOSS” or not though, you should disclose use of AI, especially since you’re selling the printed stickers.


  • Edit: yup, it’s made of AI images


    This is not an AI-generated pic, it’s a photo taken with a real camera. The logos, however, are hexagons divided into 24 triangles each, and these triangles contain often thematically related (e. g. lions for Brave) photos or photorealistic AI images (the info I found online does not state either way) cropped to best correspond to what the triangle would contain if it just had the original logo. Basically, that corner of the whale surrounded by white was taken from a face photo (or AI pic).