I had a visceral reaction to this because obviously the wish count should be decremented before the wish takes place. Even though I can’t think up a convincing technical argument for it.
If there’s parallelism/async involved, then there definitely is an argument to decrement first, execute later. Otherwise you could make a wish for the genie to just wait for an hour and then make as many wishes as you want within that hour.
But how can you decrement a future dated wish, since you can’t guarantee nothing will happen that prevents the genies ability from executing said wish? E.g. i mean like telling the Genie to do something 5 days from now, not your example which would begin immediately after making said wish.
I always thought that wish-granting is instant, even if the effects of that wish are delayed.
So if I wish for something to happen in 5 days, it’s granted in the moment and guaranteed to happen. That raises a question though: Can I wish to cancel a wish I have already made, but whose effect has not yet taken hold? On its face, this should be possible, but if we take it as a given that all valid wishes are always granted at the moment of utterance, then it might be physically/psychologically impossible for me or anyone else to revoke the wish before its IRL effect is complete.
You decrement the wish counter first, execute the action (which includes waiting those 5 days), and if it fails you increment the counter back. Something like this:
I had a visceral reaction to this because obviously the wish count should be decremented before the wish takes place. Even though I can’t think up a convincing technical argument for it.
You’d need a check to make sure they don’t wish for something not allowed (like more wishes).
If there’s parallelism/async involved, then there definitely is an argument to decrement first, execute later. Otherwise you could make a wish for the genie to just wait for an hour and then make as many wishes as you want within that hour.
What if one of the threads crashes while executing the wish? I demand warranty!
But how can you decrement a future dated wish, since you can’t guarantee nothing will happen that prevents the genies ability from executing said wish? E.g. i mean like telling the Genie to do something 5 days from now, not your example which would begin immediately after making said wish.
I always thought that wish-granting is instant, even if the effects of that wish are delayed.
So if I wish for something to happen in 5 days, it’s granted in the moment and guaranteed to happen. That raises a question though: Can I wish to cancel a wish I have already made, but whose effect has not yet taken hold? On its face, this should be possible, but if we take it as a given that all valid wishes are always granted at the moment of utterance, then it might be physically/psychologically impossible for me or anyone else to revoke the wish before its IRL effect is complete.
You decrement the wish counter first, execute the action (which includes waiting those 5 days), and if it fails you increment the counter back. Something like this:
wishes = wishes - 1; executeWish(wish).unwrap_or_else(|_| { wishes = wishes + 1; })?This way if the action fails in the future, you get a wish back and can ask something else.
Why? Shouldn’t you decrement the limited resource the user has access to in case the thing you are doing fails?