• 0 Posts
  • 6 Comments
Joined 14 days ago
cake
Cake day: March 15th, 2026

help-circle
  • Up until a couple decades ago, basically all religious texts were distributed without getting consent, giving credit or forking over royalties to their original authors. Rhymes and songs, even images, were observed and then repeated or noted down and spread.

    By todays definition, that’s piracy. Piracy is exactly the same thing, just in a digital world.

    Therefore, if piracy isn’t halal, most religious texts and imagery aren’t halal either.


    Now, looking at it the other way around, to confirm that:

    Theft is illegal. So the question stands: is piracy theft?

    That depends on the definition of theft. The old meaning of theft, so the thing, probably ruled over in religious texts, is: The unlawful taking of the property of another.

    Now, can you take something from someone else, without them loosing it? I’d argue: No!

    So, piracy isn’t theft. Piracy is copying or repeating.