• 1 Post
  • 335 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: December 16th, 2023

help-circle



  • WalnutLum@lemmy.mltoLinux@lemmy.ml•Rich Hickey: 'AI' is Not a Tool
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    5
    arrow-down
    6
    ·
    23 days ago

    Good tools have many properties LLMs lack - they are predictable, reliable, deterministic, of bounded function, hopefully simple etc.

    These are all things that LLMs have but are typically stripped or hand-waved away for the sake of convenience or ease of use.

    Predictability? Reliability? Deterministic, bounded function? The same seed pushed through a model’s weights ends with the same output. You can change the behavior for how the weights are processed, what tokens are more important than others, etc.

    Simple they are not and likely won’t be, but most models are way more controllable than most people realize. The problem is the thing that makes them interesting in novel isn’t what we can control about them, it’s about what’s not controlled. The fact that they can produce seemingly novel information is the thing everyone wants to sell, and what everyone thinks they want to buy.

    AI (in as far as an LLM is concerned) is a tool being sold, bought, and discussed as if it was something more than what it is, and articles like this don’t help the fantasification and anthropomorphization of them.





  • Works the same way as any other software optimization: lower quality computation as a shortcut.

    The predicted frames don’t use the same full stack of data that a true frame uses to render, they just use the previous frames data and the motion vectors. The rest is a very efficient nueral-network guessing algorithm based on those two pieces of data instead of the full shader stack.











  • For a lot of people for a long time your insurance card (that didn’t have a photo) was the only “identification” you had. Otherwise you had to bring your school ID, work ID etc.

    Most people don’t have drivers licenses cause they take the train. When you sign up for banks etc you usually have to get a bunch of official documentation from the local ward office with your information.

    Proof of identity in Japan has always been a bit of a hazy problem. You sign most documents still with a family stamp, so the idea of what legally is defined as identifying is kind of vague.

    Most local offices aren’t networked up, so when you move you have to register with your local ward office and the japanese beauricratic army goes and gets the previous ward office to fax over your info.

    “My Number” is the japanese governments attempt to get all that stuff wired together in one database.