If someone claims something happened on the fediverse without providing a link, they’re lying.

Evidence or GTFO.

  • 4 Posts
  • 722 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: April 30th, 2024

help-circle
  • They say you should try to lose your first 50 games as quickly as possible, just to develop your instincts. It’s very difficult to try to read things out as a beginner, but once you begin to recognize shapes and patterns, it becomes a bit easier because you start to have the right candidate moves jump out at you.

    Of course it all depends on what parts of the game are most appealing. Go involves a lot of different skills, knowledge of opening sequences, positional judgement, reading connections and life and death, counting endgame values, etc. Many people get to dan ranks just by being good at one part of the game.


  • I play Go which is mostly immune to enshittification on account of it being a 4,000 year old game, but damn if they’re not trying. Some Go servers monetize it and try to make it pay-to-win by charging a fee to let you consult an AI in the middle of a game (nothing stopping someone from just running an AI in a separate window ofc). On the other hand, you can also play on KGS which looks like this:

    It hasn’t changed in the last 20 years and it won’t change in the next 20 years. It’s still maintained and still active despite looking so old. They built a client that just works and does what it’s supposed to and nothing else, no ads, no monetization, no gimmicks. “Perfection is when there’s nothing left to take away.”



  • “I live in the US.” That explains a lot about your inexperience about the nature of China and Russia.

    Lmao! Your script is amazing. If I was from China, obviously, you’d accuse me of being a paid actor. If I say I’m from the US, then, without skipping a beat, you’re accusing me of being “inexperienced” with those countries! No matter what my life experience, you always have a way to discredit me.

    Let me guess, your script now makes you tell me that you have traveled to China and everything was rosy.

    No, I have not. Nor do I need to. The burden on evidence is on the person making the claim. I can safely reject this conspiracy theory about “slave labor camps” just as I can reject any other baseless claim, as per Russell’s Teapot.

    Also, whataboutism works like this: A claims B does Bad Thing, then B says A does Bad Thing too. I started by saying both A and B do Bad Thing,

    No, I started this conversation by saying B does Bad Thing, then you said that A does Bad Thing too. That exactly fits your own definition for whataboutism. Get fucked, lol.

    Then you said ahhha, but what about ICE.

    Lol, now you’re just obviously acting in bad faith. I brought up ICE after the accusation of whataboutism, so you don’t get to use that to justify the claim. Also, the context in which I brought up was simply showing how your conspiratorial “logic” leads to absurd conclusions, like that Switzerland has secret slave labor camps that they’re just hiding really well. It was not to show that “the US has slave labor camps just like China,” but to demonstrate that baseless claims can be made about any country, once you remove any notion of grounding them in evidence.


    When you ground your ideas in evidence, and you actually examine the historical evidence, the idea that China is doing anything remotely close to 19th century colonial practices is absurd. It’s only when you don’t do those, and also act in bad faith, twisting around logic in absurd ways, and set impossible conditions where you’re damned if you do, damned if you don’t, only then can you “justify” your positions. In reality, you take those positions not because they are reasonable, but in order to defend the West’s historical record as much as you think you can get away with.


  • You’re literally the one doing whataboutism, not me. I criticized Western colonialism and you went, “whatabout China, whatabout Russia, whatabout Iran.” And then it became clear that not only are you doing whataboutism, but it’s not even about real things that actually exist and are supported by evidence. Your response to criticism of colonialism is, “Whatabout this thing that China might hypothetically be doing?”

    I’m not in Beijing, I live in the US. But thanks for putting out yet another baseless conspiracy theory. Everyone who disagrees with you about anything is a foreign agent, very sane and sensible.


  • So, no pictures, no evidence. Just speculation on what you think might be happening.

    Why is this specific to China? We could just as easily speculate that ICE detainees are being forced to work in slave labor camps with 19th century colonial conditions. Hell, we could say the same for fucking Switzerland! Maybe they’ve just gotten really good at hiding it, who knows?

    This sort of baseless conjecture and conspiracy theory nonsense has no place in a serious discussion. If you’re not going to ground your views based on evidence, and instead just going to speculate and make shit up to whitewash colonialism, then there’s no point in trying to reason with you. Your conspiracy theories aren’t based on evidence or reason so they can’t be refuted based on evidence or reason. You only believe them because they allow you to whitewash history and create a false equivalency.



  • China hasn’t fought wars recently, but their expansion in the Third World is as cruel as the 19th century Western colonialism was.

    This is completely and utterly delusional. Outrageously false. You’re clearly ignorant of the practices of Western colonialism during that era, which included literal chattle slavery. Look up conditions in the Congo, for example, where workers were frequently punished by mutilation just for failing to meet a quota. Which countries is China subjecting to anything remotely similar to those practices? You’re attempting to whitewash this past by pretending that everyone is just as cruel, when the reality is completely different. Even modern day Western neocolonialism is nowhere remotely close to the absolute horror of 19th century colonialism.

    The reality is that China offers development loans, which it has on occasion forgiven, and which, unlike Western loans, aren’t conditional on agreeing to anti-worker domestic policies. It does not hold monopolies on the means of production, as is the case in many neocolonies of the West. When the old system of direct control and administration was replaced with the current system, generally, the natural resources that had been stolen through overt force remained in Western hands. This is why, even compared to Western neocolonialism, China is much better for the underdeveloped world.

    But forget about China, if you’re going to whitewash the actual history of slavery and colonialism like this then I’m not interested in discussing anything further with you. Nothing comparable in scale and cruelty exists in the modern day (with the possible exception of Israel, being a holdout from “old-school” colonialism).


  • The problem with the Western system is not just corruption, it’s that it’s built on a structure of neocolonialism that dominates the entire world. We are opposed to that social relation. You can compare, say, the US vs Iran and say that the US system is more progressive, but opposing the Iran War should not imply that we like Iran, or that we want to make US society more like Iranian society. But, while the Iran War seems to be unpopular enough to be an exception, in other cases this kind of line is often used against us, and against anyone who genuinely opposes the imperial project. Those who opposed the war in Afghanistan, for example, were branded as terrorist sympathizers, regardless of how they actually felt about Al Qaida or their actual reasons for opposing the war.


  • The Nordic countries are allowed to do what they do because the cost benefit calculation was that it was easier to secure their loyalty by allowing them some progressive policies (likewise, this is why the US historically invested in a handful of regions like Germany, Taiwan, and South Korea). But there are many countries in the global south that have tried to follow the Nordic model, the trouble is, they’re not allowed to because the cost-benefit analysis is different. When they try, the CIA overthrows them and installs a dictator who will enact exploitative policies and keep the cheap goods flowing. When they take steps to stop that from happening, Western leftists denounce them as “authoritarian.”

    Science and research are followed in AES (actually existing socialism) countries. Look at the response to COVID, for example. While in the US, people where crowding into stores to panic buy toilet paper, Vietnam was delivering free groceries directly to the doorsteps of people under lockdown.

    What are the examples of “bad” socialism “benefiting the wealthy rather than the majority?” Socialist states, including Vietnam, Cuba, China, etc have implemented policies that have improved people lives by any objective metric, literacy, life expectancy, doctors and teachers per capita, etc. Granted, they sometimes have little choice but to allow some economic concessions, as a condition to participate in the global market. China’s reforms in the 80’s lead to 800 million people being lifted out of extreme poverty, for example. When a country doesn’t make such concessions and gets sanctioned or blockaded, things tend to go very poorly for them, which also gets held up as a “failure of socialism.” Damned if you do, damned if you don’t.

    If you actually evaluate AES countries, based on reasonable expectations or on what they had before, they are not failures at all. The problem is that people don’t understand the challenges and threats that they have to navigate, and so they have unreasonable, impossible expectations of them. Again, I wish we lived in a world where it was possible to simply copy-paste social democratic policies into the global south, but it isn’t. History has proven quite clearly that that isn’t the world we live in. Y’all just never bother to actually study the histories of global south countries, so you don’t understand the severity of the threats they face.


  • I used to be somewhere in the neighborhood of anarchist/social democrat, the way most people on lemmy who aren’t MLs are. I was just as “anti-tankie” as anyone.

    While trying to really define what I believed, I stumbled across Progress and Poverty by Henry George, and it really clicked for me. It made the case that no one should have a specific right of ownership over land and natural resources, so they should be considered publicly owned and used to fund the state. Without getting into the details of the idea itself, I was convinced that it could work, as a compromise that would fix the worst parts of capitalism and essentially get the best parts of both. That, if it were enacted in a few small countries and able to compete on a level playing field, it would prove itself successful and serve as a model for everyone to follow. But this raised the question of, if that’s true, why hasn’t it happened already?

    This question caused me to take an interest in a bunch of random small countries around the world that had experimented with asserting state control over their natural resources, and using them to fund social spending for the benefit of the people. And what did I find? Let’s look at a case study.

    Mohammad Mossadegh of Iran was the prime example for me, because he wasn’t a Marxist at all, he had no ties whatsoever to the USSR, and did everything right. He attempted to assert control over Iran’s oil, which had been stolen outright by the British on a massive scale, in order to use it to uplift the people, who were incredibly poor and destitute. He believed in and upheld democratic ideals, and that exactly how the CIA was able to freely operate in Iran and oust him in favor of a literal monarchy.

    Mossadegh refused to censor the press, when the CIA controlled 90% of the newspapers in the country, which constantly printed negative stories about him. He refused to suppress demonstrations, when the CIA was hiring them to march, both against him, and for him while wrecking shit and turning people against him. Finally, a US diplomat fed him a false story about the embassy receiving death threats from his supporters, and he was so moved, and so concerned about remaining friendly with the US, that he put out a radio message instructing his supporters to stand down. The next day, the CIA attacked his residence and there was no one to come to his aid.

    It took me a long time to really wrestle with the full implications of that case study, and the similar stories that I found all around the world. But what I eventually realized is that the reason so many socialist states are authoritarian is not because they just want to be, it’s survivorship bias. And while the US is able to act as a global hegemon, the kind of system that I idealized, the kind of system Mossadegh was trying to build, will never be allowed to compete fairly. In fact, it is precisely because it might work to fix the worst parts of capitalism that it cannot be permitted, because a lot of powerful people get very, very rich off of those parts. It’s not about the food, it’s about keeping those ants in line.

    I would much rather live in the world where the Marxist-Leninists were wrong. I would love it if countries around the world could try out all sorts of different systems, without fear of outside interference, so that different systems could compete and rise or fall on their own merits. If, when I looked into history I had found something different, I’d probably still agree with the criticisms I did before. But, unfortunately, that’s just not the world we live in. When you actually study history, what you’ll find in nearly every case is that the US tried to meddle in their affairs, to the detriment of the average person, and they were successful whenever they were not suppressed by force.

    And that’s how I became a “tankie.”

    From The Jakarta Method:

    This was another very difficult question I had to ask my interview subjects, especially the leftists from Southeast Asia and Latin America. When we would get to discussing the old debates between peaceful and armed revolution; between hardline Marxism and democratic socialism, I would ask:

    “Who was right?”

    In Guatemala, was it Árbenz or Che who had the right approach? Or in Indonesia, when Mao warned Aidit that the PKI should arm themselves, and they did not? In Chile, was it the young revolutionaries in the MIR who were right in those college debates, or the more disciplined, moderate Chilean Communist Party?

    Most of the people I spoke with who were politically involved back then believed fervently in a nonviolent approach, in gradual, peaceful, democratic change. They often had no love for the systems set up by people like Mao. But they knew that their side had lost the debate, because so many of their friends were dead. They often admitted, without hesitation or pleasure, that the hardliners had been right. Aidit’s unarmed party didn’t survive. Allende’s democratic socialism was not allowed, regardless of the détente between the Soviets and Washington.

    Looking at it this way, the major losers of the twentieth century were those who believed too sincerely in the existence a liberal international order, those who trusted too much in democracy, or too much in what the United States said it supported, rather than what it really supported—what the rich countries said, rather than what they did. That group was annihilated.


  • Thank you. There are some types like that, who overcorrect or take things too far. That Jank4life guy isn’t exactly the best representative of our instance with his low effort bait, and I have a lot of disagreements with Geneva_Convenience as well. But I have a lot of respect for Cowbee and Diva, for example.

    Personally, I would like it if there was a place on the fediverse that was for more formal, academic level discussions, where personal attacks and accusations were strictly moderated on all sides. I think that people act more defensive and rude when they expect the other side to, and it creates a vicious cycle, which can also lead to people adopting “maximalist” positions. I’ve thought about creating a comm like that myself, but I doubt people would actually participate or accept me as an impartial moderator.



  • I disagree with that. If I criticize western imperialism, it’s often assumed, regardless of what I actually say, that I’m supporting US geopolitical rivals. This has pretty much always been the case throughout history. Call for peace, say, after 9/11, and you’d be accused of supporting Bin Laden. Since the enemy is always painted as the more evil and aggressive party, it means that those who oppose war and imperialism will always get labelled as being the most aggressive and imperialistic. Historically, this was even the cause of the breakdown of the Second International, the split between social democrats and Marxist-Leninists. MLs opposed WWI while social democratic parties across Europe supported it.

    And naturally, part of opposing war means refuting blatant misinformation about the enemy, because if the hawks can say whatever they want about them they can naturally make it look like war is an obvious choice. But the moment you start refuting misinformation, for example, the story about everyone in North Korea having to get the same haircut, you are now “defending” or “glazing” North Korea, regardless of any other, more grounded criticisms you might have of it.

    For generations, the Western left has allowed such misinformation to run rampant, in order to avoid being associated with states like the USSR, and the result have been disastrous. Historically, unions expelled communists and radicals and did everything they could to appease the US government, and they were gutted anyway. Now, things have gone so far that even conservative liberals like Biden get painted as “communists.” What I said before, criticizing US imperialism, is more than enough for people to label me a communist, a tankie, whatever. Maybe you wouldn’t, but others would. The comment I responded to was specifically looking to “ragebait tankies” by glazing US imperialism.

    In my view, we should speak the truth regardless of whatever labels are assigned to us, communist, socialist, red, tankie, pinko, they can accuse us of what they will. Wear whatever label with pride, and you can at least have a chance to define it for ourselves.

    You might as well ignore it, or love the word instead, because you ain’t done nothing if you ain’t been called a red



  • Can I ragebait them?

    Always 😄

    US certainly had a bunch of illicit, criminal side quests

    Lmao. Every bad thing that the US did was just a “side quest” that deviates from the overall pure and good intentions. Every bad thing the USSR did shows that they were inherently evil.

    Mohammad Mossadegh was the progressive, peaceful, prime minister of Iran, who had zero alignment with the Soviets and only tried to assert Iran’s autonomy over its natural resources against the British colonizers who had built their entire empire off of stealing Iranian oil - deposed by the CIA in the name of “anti-communism,” and replaced by a literal monarch that spent decades hunting down and annihilating the Iranian left with secret police. But of course, that’s just a “side quest.”

    Operation Condor, in which the US engaged in widespread election interference across South America, promoting right wing authoritarians and setting up “banana republics” to keep the cheap goods coming, that whole continent was just a little “side quest.”

    Vietnam, Laos, Cambodia, where the US dropped massive amounts of chemical weapons on poor rice farmers trying to assert control of their own land and resources. Indonesia, the mass killings of hundreds of thousands of activists, teachers, ethnic minorities, etc, by the US-backed Suharto regime, once again, a regrettable little “side quest.”

    Exactly how many countries do you have to do “side quests” of terror and looting in the name of “stopping totalitarianism” before they count as the “main quest?”


  • People are generally too obsessed with the current thing and the news cycle rather than the bigger picture.

    For example, I hate Trump for ICE, the Iran War, and affordability. I hated him for those things yesterday and I’ll hate him for those things tomorrow. But people seem to think there needs to be constant, wall-to-wall coverage about how every time he sneezes it’s the worst thing anyone’s ever done and his mucus is now defiling the dignity of the noble halls of blah blah blah. It’s counterproductive for so many reasons, first it lets the enemy control the focus, second people just get tired of hearing it, third it takes the focus away from the GOP in general, when Trump is a lame duck who’ll be gone soon anyway. And the shit about how he’ll cancel elections was always exaggerated and unrealistic, but it was taken as absolute fact, you had people being like, “Oh, you sweet Summer child,” and whatnot just if you acknowledged the midterms would happen. So now those people have egg on their face and someone might see that and think, “Oh, people were being alarmist, Trump isn’t as bad as people thought after all.”

    Not me, though obviously. Because I still hate him for ICE, the Iran War, and affordability. The same reasons I hated him yesterday and the same reasons I will hate him tomorrow.