

You get gas by products you can use to keep things going but it’s a lot of energy to dry the feedstock if needed and get it up to temperature. Again, you can make char crudely, but it’s environmental benefit drops quickly.
Fortunately, woodland creatures don’t hire lawyers


You get gas by products you can use to keep things going but it’s a lot of energy to dry the feedstock if needed and get it up to temperature. Again, you can make char crudely, but it’s environmental benefit drops quickly.


Just watch the pH. Hotter chars are more basic. The benefit you’re seeing is probably due to increased water holding capacity and the microbe habitat I mention earlier.


Because soils in and of themselves are generally productive. Aerating soils (tilling) boosts the microbial community, making it consume organic matter in the soil. Biochar is highly stable, so it wouldn’t be consumed, but instead the existing organic matter, which acts as the massive pool nutrients would then be consumed. So what you’d see, is a priming effect at least a few years, followed by a drop in soil productivity.
Biochar is useful as a soil amendment in the right conditions, but its effect is really situational and highly dependent on cooking temperatures and feedstock. I used stuff cooked around 380C in an attempt to allow for some of the feedstock’s more available carbon forms to be accessible to microbes. It didn’t really work like that, but I ended up with an N boost in my soils, which we suspected was due to proving more microbial habitat (due to char surface area).
It’s also really good at catching and holding onto leaching metals, and nitrogen too, in the right conditions


Hey, I can answer this one. I did my M.Sc on amending soils with biochar.
I’m not sure what Stockholm is doing, though.
To get good recovery of biochar, you need a pretty controlled environment. It’s also energy intensive to make; you need a heat source that’s not going to produce CO2, ideally, and cut into the benefit that you’d get by sequestering carbon in the first place. Like if it takes 1 ton of waste wood fuel to make 1 ton of biochar, it’s pretty much a wash. You could use green energy I suppose, like it you had a hydro grid set up to fire whatever furnace you’re cooking the stuff in, but that’s not always available or scalable (in the sense you can do it everywhere).
You CAN make biochar crudely, and we’ve been doing so for centuries, but the rub is that your recovery quickly drops and decreases in recovery are increases in CO2 produced. I was toying with this idea to manage non-merchantable timber on mines, and using the char as a soil amendment.
Suppose everything DOES work the way we want, though. Good recovery, cheap energy, people onboard. We now have a mountain of char and no place to put it. You could go underground mines). Stockpiling it aboveground would a nightmare and massive fire hazard… Etc. Etc.
I like using char to store carbon and it’ll stay for a long time, but you can’t just capture it at the source like you can with other forms of carbon capture and storage. Those other methods don’t work well either… At least with char you have a solid to manage rather than stuffing gas underground and hoping the earth doesn’t fart.
Like a lot of things, char use like you envision is ‘we would if we could but we can’t so we wont’.


What is a tally and why are we whacking them?


You must be younger, because this diagram is spot on for me
Blast it, how do I pin a comment… I just get stupid mod options to nuke it. This needs to be put on the fridge.
Did Danielle Smith (Alberta’s Premier) post this?


They’re spying on us for the government. If you had more than two it would be a flock camera.


Snoopervisor
Well that’s disappointing


This trend is gaining traction. It stated with twitter, then other platforms followed, Reddit does it now too.
You can’t monetize unlogged in traffic I guess.
Bingo. It’s like this here too.
Not usually. For my sphere, you need field time to understand how things work. The academic smarts gives you the horsepower to the hardest problems, but it doesn’t replace the foundational skills that comprise 97% of the work
Now it’s time to get your hands dirty with just about everything that comes your way and build up that experience. You’re not meant to be a master of your field, you’re meant to be able to think intelligently about your subject matter
Within your area of expertise too, even. In my field, Ph.Ds are viewed as being overqualified with not enough field experience


Wiebo Ludwig has entered the chat
No, all good. It’s been a while since I thought about char, and honestly a lot do my stuff was based on ‘what does it do?’