That’s the western claim, but Xinjiang is a special province of China called “autonomous region”, with more powers to local politics than most others. Uyghur people can study Uyghur language at school (unlike for exmaple Occitanian people in France) and their culture is preserved. You wanna see a cultural genocide in real time? Look up the population of Occitanian speakers over the past 100 years and the French policy towards Occitanian.
That’s the entire point of why tankies like me bring up such topics. When Europeans insist in the “superiority and democratic rule” of Europe vs. say China, it’s because we remain oblivious to the sins of our own countries while we’re constantly bombarded with propaganda against socialist projects. You can get started with the Wikipedia article on Occitan Language if you’re interested.
I don’t care what France is doing when I’m talking about China
Thats the entire point. There is immense propaganda about China while we literally don’t know what happens in the neighboring country. If there were an equal amount of contributions in .world about repression of Occitan as there is about China, I would make it less of a point to bring it up constantly. It’s not deviating, it’s not letting anti-China discourse dominate in the platform
This person isn’t engaging in good faith - they present as though they have engaged with a wide range of sources, but they extremely clearly have not (if the blatant whattaboutism didn’t tip you off already). They don’t source the controversial claims, either.
That’s the western claim, but Xinjiang is a special province of China called “autonomous region”, with more powers to local politics than most others. Uyghur people can study Uyghur language at school (unlike for exmaple Occitanian people in France) and their culture is preserved. You wanna see a cultural genocide in real time? Look up the population of Occitanian speakers over the past 100 years and the French policy towards Occitanian.
Yes, they have largely stopped doing it, which is good.
No, it’s not good that it’s happening somewhere else. I haven’t heard about that at all. Maybe we should make it an issue so they stop too???
This is not a zero sum game. I don’t care what France is doing when I’m talking about China or vice versa, I just want less bad things in the world
That’s the entire point of why tankies like me bring up such topics. When Europeans insist in the “superiority and democratic rule” of Europe vs. say China, it’s because we remain oblivious to the sins of our own countries while we’re constantly bombarded with propaganda against socialist projects. You can get started with the Wikipedia article on Occitan Language if you’re interested.
Thats the entire point. There is immense propaganda about China while we literally don’t know what happens in the neighboring country. If there were an equal amount of contributions in .world about repression of Occitan as there is about China, I would make it less of a point to bring it up constantly. It’s not deviating, it’s not letting anti-China discourse dominate in the platform
This person isn’t engaging in good faith - they present as though they have engaged with a wide range of sources, but they extremely clearly have not (if the blatant whattaboutism didn’t tip you off already). They don’t source the controversial claims, either.